Alternatives to the Catalinbread Dirty Little Secret MkIII

$96.75via Reverb

Shared character: middle, classic rock, lead

Carl Martin Rock Drive

Carl Martin

$89via Reverb

Shared character: higher gain, hard rock, middle

Boss SD-1 Super OverDrive

Boss

$59via Reverb

Shared character: middle, response, classic rock

Warm Audio ODD Box V1

Warm Audio

$89.99via Reverb

Shared character: response, high gain settings, overdrive

Dunlop MXR M77 Custom Modified Badass OD

MXR

44% similarity

$119.98via Reverb

Shared character: high gain settings, hard rock, classic rock

Mooer Micro Preamp US Gold 100

Mooer

42% similarity

$89.48via Reverb

Shared character: middle, response, high gain settings

Electro-Harmonix Nano Operation Overlord

Electro-Harmonix

$101.40via Reverb

similar tone character

Digitech DOD Boneshaker

Digitech

$118.97via Reverb

similar tone character

Boutique & premium upgrades

Friedman IR-J Jake E. Lee Preamp

Friedman

51% similarity

$499via Reverb

Shared character: hard rock, response, high gain settings

Origin Effects Halcyon Gold Overdrive

Origin Effects

49% similarity

$278.25via Reverb

Shared character: response, classic rock, overdrive

Blackstar HT-Metal

Blackstar

$257.42via Reverb

Shared character: hard rock, middle, response

JAM Pedals TubeDreamer MK2

Jam Pedals

$250.46via Reverb

Shared character: response, classic rock, high gain settings

Beetronics Overhive Mid-Gain Overdrive

Beetronics

44% similarity

$227.01via Reverb

Shared character: middle, classic rock, high gain settings

Bondi Effects Sick As Overdrive

Bondi Effects

42% similarity

$219via Reverb

Shared character: middle, overdrive

Browne Amplification Alkene Nashville Overdrive

Browne Amplification

42% similarity

$229via Reverb

Shared character: middle, response, lead

J. Rockett HRM Hot Rubber Monkey V2

J Rockett

$225.39via Reverb

similar tone character

Blackstar Dept. 10 Dual Distortion

Blackstar

$206.77via Reverb

similar tone character

Mad Professor Supreme Overdrive

Mad Professor

$272.05via Reverb

similar tone character

J. Rockett PXO Phil X Signature Overdrive

J Rockett

$319.97via Reverb

similar tone character

Crazy Tube Circuits Ziggy V2

Crazy Tube Circuits

$175.99via Reverb

similar tone character

Closest-sounding alternatives

Dunlop Way Huge WM31 Supa-Lead Overdrive

Dunlop

55% similarity

Shared character: hard rock, middle, response

Fulltone OCD

Fulltone

51% similarity

Shared character: hard rock, middle, response

Fulltone OCD V2

Fulltone

51% similarity

Shared character: classic rock, high gain settings, overdrive

Friedman BE-OD

Friedman

50% similarity

$169.99via Reverb

Shared character: higher gain, hard rock, middle

Alexander Pedals Hot Pink Drive

Alexander Pedals

49% similarity

$150via Reverb

Shared character: classic rock, lead, overdrive

Browne Amps The Protein

Browne Amplification

Shared character: high gain settings, lead, overdrive

Wampler Pedals Tweed '57

Wampler

Shared character: middle, fuzz, high gain settings

J. Rockett Animal

J Rockett

$129via Reverb

Shared character: hard rock, high gain settings

Rarebird effects Hatchet Overdrive

Rarebird Effects

Shared character: higher gain, hard rock, lead

EWS Eric Gales Brute Drive

Ews

Shared character: response, lead, overdrive

Maxon OD808

Maxon

$134.12via Reverb

Shared character: hard rock, middle, response

Dunlop MXR® Wylde Audio Overdrive WA44

Dunlop