Pedals that stack with the Caroline Guitar Company Icarus V2

Dr. Scientist Frazz Dazzler

What Dr. Scientist Frazz Dazzler brings here leans toward fuzzy — that's worth building a pairing around

Ashdown Geezer Butler Signature

Ashdown Geezer Butler Signature leans toward high gain, and that's a real, usable character to pair with

Walrus Audio Lillian

Keep Walrus Audio Lillian after Caroline Guitar Company Icarus V2 in the signal chain, clear of Caroline Guitar Company Icarus V2's own gain stage

Pigtronix Philosopher's Tone Micro

Pigtronix Philosopher's Tone Micro's own sustaining character is the real reason this is worth trying

Strymon BigSky

Strymon BigSky's ambient voice goes after Caroline Guitar Company Icarus V2 in the signal chain — it's not there to compete with Caroline Guitar Company Icarus V2's own germanium character — goes in the amp's FX loop (or last, into a clean amp)

Malekko Electro-Harmonix Memory Toy Analog Delay

Put Malekko Electro-Harmonix Memory Toy Analog Delay after Caroline Guitar Company Icarus V2 in the signal chain, clear of Caroline Guitar Company Icarus V2's own gain stage — goes in the amp's FX loop (or last, into a clean amp)